DA leader Geordin Hill-Lewis opens up about ActionSA’s demand to drop Helen Zille as Johannesburg mayor

DA leader Geordin Hill-Lewis said it has been extraordinarily difficult for them to swallow ActionSA’s request that Helen Zille be dropped as Johannesburg mayor.

He shared his views on this request on Radio 702, saying that he is not sure that it would be right for the people of Johannesburg.

In the 2026 local government elections, the Democratic Alliance, with Helen Zille as its mayoral candidate, received 34.8% of the vote in Johannesburg.

The African National Congress (ANC) was second with 20.3%, followed by ActionSA with 16.3%, and the EFF with 6.5%.

Many people rejoiced, expecting a DA-ActionSA coalition where the DA governs Johannesburg and Ekurhuleni, and ActionSA governs Tshwane.

This is indeed what ActionSA leader Herman Mashaba offered Hill-Lewis, but with a caveat. He had to drop Helen Zille and Cilliers Brink.

Commenting on this request, he said that this request was “extraordinarily difficult for us to swallow”.

“I’m not sure that it would be right to the people of Johannesburg who voted. A plurality of the people of Johannesburg voted for Helen Zille,” he said.

However, he did not say it was a deal breaker. “We have to consider the requirements or stipulations of all of our potential partners,” he said.

“I don’t want to rule out any of our potential partners. We’ve had productive conversations with all of them.”

He admitted that they were still far apart on a number of things, including the Zille demand, but that does not mean they are shutting off those engagements.

“What I am saying clearly is that I don’t like this concept of red lines and throwing around the phrase no deal,” Hill-Lewis said.

“You can start out very far from one another and you can slowly, but surely, inch-by-inch make your way to find one another somewhere in the middle.”

“There is a lot of potential for us to work with ActionSA, and we just have to keep talking to each other until we can find one another.”

ActionSA explains its demand regarding Helen Zille and Cilliers Brink

ActionSA national chairperson Michael Beaumont

ActionSA national chairperson Michael Beaumont shared details about their request to sideline Helen Zille and Cilliers Brink as part of a coalition deal with the DA.

Speaking to Radio 702, he said that ActionSA had adopted a policy that they do not put failed mayors back in to lead municipalities.

“That is a problem for Cilliers Brink. His governance track record is up there with Kabelo Gwamanda, who, in fact, did less damage than Brink did.”

“I don’t think Cilliers Brink has gotten any better at leading municipalities in the last couple of years.”

“The City of Tshwane finances that Nasiphi Moya inherited from Cilliers Brink were literally bankrupt.”

“Its liquidity was 0.4, Eskom debt grew from 2020 to 2024 by R6.8 billion, and audit outcomes had regressed to adverse levels.”

Moving to the DA’s mayoral candidate in Johannesburg, Helen Zille, Beaumont said that she has collapsed stable and functioning coalition governments in Johannesburg.

“We want to see coalition partners who are going to roll up their sleeves and do what is needed to provide five years of stable and effective government,” he said.

He added that when Herman Mashaba was the mayor of Johannesburg, the DA told him to stop wasting time delivering services to people who don’t pay rates.

“Now, that kind of thinking is incongruous with ActionSA’s idea of how we would like to govern,” Beaumont said.

He explained that ActionSA sees a problem with Brink and Zille in Tshwane and Johannesburg, which needs to be addressed.

“We see that problem, and we are putting this forward as a solution to that problem. If the DA doesn’t like our solution, they should come up with one of their own,” he said.

“The DA is welcome to come back to us and communicate what their ideas would be to solve the impasse.”

He added that the DA’s response to the request about Zille and Brink is that ActionSA should simply get over it.

“You can’t get over it because these are very serious problems, and they have not changed their ways in respect of their approach to coalition government.”

“But let’s hear what they have to say. Maybe they’ve got creative ideas, maybe they’ve thought about ideas that we haven’t even thought about yet.”

You have read 1 out of 5 free articles. Log in or register for unlimited access.

  1. Timeplace
    17 November 2026 at 06:26

    The individual is not bigger than the party, the people voted for the DA not Helen….so if the vote was abought policy and strategy then dropping Helen should not be a problem…