Helen Zille versus South Africa: DA leader Geordin Hill-Lewis says they will not sacrifice Zille to keep the ANC out of Gauteng metros

DA leader Geordin Hill-Lewis indicated that they would rather hand Johannesburg, Tshwane, and Ekurhuleni to the ANC and ActionSA than drop Helen Zille as Johannesburg mayor.

He shared his views regarding ActionSA’s demand to replace Zille and Tshwane mayoral candidate Cilliers Brink to facilitate a coalition during a Radio 702 interview.

From the outset, ActionSA leader Herman Mashaba said they would like to partner with the DA in Gauteng, on the condition that Zille and Brink step back.

If this happens, it clears the path for ActionSA and the DA to form a coalition where the DA runs Johannesburg and Ekurhuleni, and ActionSA runs Tshwane.

The alternative, which looks increasingly likely, is that ActionSA will partner with the ANC and other parties to form coalitions in Johannesburg, Tshwane, and Ekurhuleni.

Mashaba said that negotiations with the ANC have progressed well and that they have not reached a deal-breaking point.

“They gave us a written proposal yesterday, and we responded to them last night. We are now waiting for their feedback,” he said.

ActionSA national chairperson Michael Beaumont has also said that negotiations with the ANC were going well and that he expected a positive outcome.

This aligned with Patriotic Alliance (PA) leader Gayton McKenzie’s prediction that the ANC will partner with ActionSA, the EFF, and the MK Party in the Gauteng metros.

This will result in the ANC governing Ekurhuleni, while Mashaba will become Johannesburg mayor and Nasiphi Moya will remain Tshwane mayor.

Hill-Lewis said it is unlikely that the Democratic Alliance could match the ANC’s offer to ActionSA. However, he said it could hurt ActionSA in the long run.

“That would be a terrible mistake, but that is how the political system works if a party does not get a majority,” he said.

“It would be a profound error, and the voters will punish them dearly, but that is my view and time will tell.”

Helen Zille versus the interests of South Africa

DA leader Geordin Hill-Lewis

Hill-Lewis admitted that a deal between the ANC and ActionSA across the Gauteng metros would cause further damage to Johannesburg, Ekurhuleni, and Tshwane.

“It would be more of the same instability. It would require a six- or seven-party coalition in Johannesburg to make that work, so you will get more of the same,” he said.

During her campaign, Zille also said that the 2026 local government election was the last chance to reverse Johannesburg’s decline.

She warned that anything other than a stable DA-led administration would push Johannesburg past the point of recovery.

She stated that another term of coalition chaos involving parties like the ANC, EFF, and MK would push Johannesburg to a level where no one can fix it.

ActionSA offered the Democratic Alliance a stable coalition in Johannesburg to fix the city, with a mayor of its choosing, as long as it was not Zille.

Radio 702 asked Hill-Lewis why the party does not ask Zille to step aside, given the value a DA-led coalition would bring to Johannesburg and South Africa.

Hill-Lewis said that this was difficult for them to swallow. “There’s something slightly odd and even preposterous about the suggestion,” he said.

“We did not hide her name as other parties did. We put her forward, made a clear offer, and that offer actually received the majority of the votes,” he said.

He argued that it was not fair for ActionSA to demand that sacrifice on the basis of a deeply felt personal issue.

“The question should rather be put to ActionSA. This person received a plurality of support from the voters. Is it worth sacrificing because of personal issues?” he said.

Hill-Lewis argued that, although these issues are serious for Mashaba, they have nothing to do with the governance of that metro.

Gayton McKenzie says nobody in the DA has the guts to tell Helen Zille to step aside

PA leader Gayton McKenzie

Gayton McKenzie said in a Biznews interview that no one in the Democratic Alliance has the guts or power to tell Zille to step aside.

“There is no one in the DA who has a wish to be fired. If you tell Helen Zille she can’t be mayor, you might as well go pack your bags. That’s never going to happen,” he said.

Helen Zille is also unlikely to voluntarily step aside to facilitate a deal with ActionSA, which McKenzie said would mean the DA would lose all Gauteng metros.

When she was asked about stepping aside, she described it as a preposterous proposal, since she had received the most votes in Johannesburg.

“Imagine if the DA had received 16% and Herman Mashaba had led the party that got 35%,” she said.

“If the DA’s condition was that the person for whom 35% of Johannesburg voted may not be the mayor, it would be absurd. No one would even entertain it.”

“What Herman Mashaba is saying is that his rancour is more important than the voters of Johannesburg, and then he calls us arrogant.”

McKenzie added that Zille will not give Herman Mashaba the accolade of saying he finished her political career. “It is not going to happen,” he said.

This means that a deal between the DA and ActionSA is unlikely, which will prevent Zille from becoming Johannesburg mayor.

“Anybody who thinks Helen Zille is going to be the mayor of Johannesburg can forget that dream,” McKenzie said.

Apart from the negative impact on South Africa, he said this will play into the hands of the ANC at the national level.

He argued that by locking the DA out of the main metros, the ANC strips the party of its bargaining power in the government of national unity (GNU).

“If the DA does not behave at the GNU level, the ANC will tell them that it has the option to work with the EFF and MK,” he said.

“It removed the leverage the DA had, which is the threat that the government will collapse if they leave.”

You have read 1 out of 5 free articles. Log in or register for unlimited access.

Which option do you prefer?

View results

Loading ... Loading ...